| First Name | Last Name | Year Awarded | Category | |
| Marc | Adelman | 2012 | Alumni Association | |
| Gene R. | Alessandrini | 2002 | Educator | |
| Carlos | Alvarez | 2003 | Community | |
| Teresa | Aversa | 2004 | Community | |
| Ann | Baccari | 2003 | Educator | |
| Christine Mariano | Beady | 2018 | Community | |
| Joan | Bergen | 2015 | Educator | |
| Paul | Berger | 2015 | Community | |
| Rita | Bosari | 2003 | Alumni Association | |
| Reverend Derek | Bowen | 2006 | Community | |
| Dr. Joseph . | Brancato | 1960 | Educator | |
| Adele R. | Capolupo | 2015 | Educator | |
| Dr. Josephine | Caporelli | 1997 | Educator | |
| Ed | Capuano | 2001 | Alumni Association | |
| Tom | Cardella | 2005 | Community | |
| John | Carrozza | 2018 | Educator | |
| Giovanna | Cavaliere | 2005 | Alumni Association | |
| Wei | Chen | 2022 | Community | |
| Lucy Cantor | Cohen | 2005 | Community | |
| Harvey | Cohen | 2005 | Alumni Association | |
| Valerie | Costanzo | 1999 | Educator | |
| Lillian Fireman | Cralle | 2011 | Community | |
| John | Curto | 2014 | Educator | |
| Joann Abate | Custodio | 2017 | Educator | |
| Dave | Dabrow | 1960 | Educator | |
| Nita Carol | Daly | 1992 | ||
| Frank | DeFlavia | 1997 | Community | |
| Peter | DeIuliis | 2018 | Community | |
| Angie | Demeis | 1995 | Alumni Association | |
| Regina | DeShields | 2016 | Educator | |
| Judge Alfred | DiBona | 1996 | Community | |
| Dominic | DiCicco | 1992 | Community | |
| Dr. George | DiPilato | 2001 | Educator | |
| Thomas | DiRenzo | 2015 | Alumni Association | |
| Anthony | DiSabato | 2007 | Community | |
| John | DiSaverio | 2010 | Community | |
| Deacon Fred | Druding | 2008 | Community | |
| Carmen | Durante | 2005 | Community | |
| William | Esher | 2015 | Educator | |
| Dr. Anthony | Evangelisto | 2016 | Educator | |
| Benito | Farnese | 2000 | Educator | |
| Jean | Farnese | 2000 | Alumni Association | |
| Senator Larry | Farnese | 2009 | Community | |
| Marco | Farnese | 2001 | Educator | |
| Leona | Feldman | Community | ||
| Ben | Ferrara | 2017 | Community | |
| John | Ferrara | 2017 | Community | |
| Ron | Ferrara | 2012 | Educator | |
| Robert | Fisicaro | 2011 | Educator | |
| William | Flynn | 1999 | Alumni Association | |
| Anna L. | Forte | 2004 | Educator | |
| Dr. Edmond | Forte | 1993 | Educator | |
| Nuzio | Fortuna | 2004 | Alumni Association | |
| John | Frangipani | 2003 | Educator | |
| Joseph | Franzini | 2010 | Educator | |
| Joyce | Garozzo | 2008 | Educator | |
| Dottie | Giannatassio | 2007 | Educator | |
| James | Gibbs | 1998 | Educator | |
| Harry | Gilbert | 2019 | Educator | |
| Robert | Giorgio | 2002 | Community | |
| Dr. Arnold | Giusini | 1997 | Educator | |
| Rose | Goldschneider | 1954 | Alumni Association | |
| Samuel | Goldschneider | 1981 | Educator | |
| Fran | Guiles | 2019 | Alumni Association | |
| Otis III | Hackney | 2016 | Educator | |
| Mark | Hoffman | 2013 | Educator | |
| Ray | Innaurato | 2009 | Community | |
| Gene | Jordan | 2012 | Educator | |
| Herbert | Jung | 2017 | Educator | |
| Gilda | LaBrasca | 2003 | Educator | |
| Charles | LaGrossa | Alumni Association | ||
| Althea | Leslie | 2022 | Educator | |
| Charles | Leuzzi | 2017 | Community | |
| Colonel Ralph | Logan | 1998 | Community | |
| Chuck | Madison | 2011 | Educator | |
| Joseph | Manzo | 2006 | Educator | |
| Louise | Marella | 1997 | Community | |
| Father Nicholas | Martorano | 2014 | Community | |
| Matt | McCarthy | 1997 | Alumni Association | |
| Robin | Mitchell | 2010 | Alumni Association | |
| Ken | Mugler | 2010 | Alumni Association | |
| Carlo | Musciano | 2007 | Alumni Association | |
| Jay | Myers | 1998 | Alumni Association | |
| Elizabeth | Olivieri | 2017 | Alumni Association | |
| Joseph | Ominsky | 1996 | ||
| Kerry | Pacifico | 1995 | Community | |
| Yvette | Palmer | 2019 | Educator | |
| Dominic | Paranzino | 1999 | Educator | |
| Henrietta | Patrick | 2005 | Educator | |
| Vivian | Perpiglia | 2011 | Alumni Association | |
| Anthony | Pirollo | 2013 | Community | |
| Joe | Pitt | 1957 | Educator | |
| John | Pizza | 2008 | Community | |
| Dan | Podolsky | 2000 | Alumni Association | |
| Dr. Robert | Poindexter | 1996 | Educator | |
| Will | Pollins | 2009 | Alumni Association | |
| Aurelio | Pontarelli | 2015 | Educator | |
| Mary | Popolo | 2006 | Community | |
| Mark | Rago | 2019 | Community | |
| Sunny | Richman | 2016 | Educator | |
| John | Rigolizzo | 1996 | Educator | |
| Edward | Rocco | 2013 | Alumni Association | |
| Thomas | Sebastian | 2012 | Educator | |
| Cecilia | Shubin | 1996 | Alumni Association | |
| Dr, Harry | Shubin | 1996 | Alumni Association | |
| Anthony “Mex” | Siani | 1984 | Educator | |
| Don | Snyder | 2013 | Educator | |
| Mark | Squilla | 2014 | Community | |
| Annette | Squillace | 2002 | Alumni Association | |
| Ray | Talbot | 2004 | Alumni Association | |
| Joseph | Tedesco | 2022 | Educator | |
| Lt. Col. Bruno | Terlizzi | 1998 | Alumni Association | |
| Bridget | Termini | 2002 | Educator | |
| Vincent | Termini | 2008 | Community | |
| Commissioner John | Timmony | 1998 | Community | |
| Steve | Todarello | 1999 | Alumni Association | |
| Dottie | Todaro | 2002 | Alumni Association | |
| Joseph | Vento | 2006 | Community | |
| Robert | Venuti | 2014 | Alumni Association | |
| Steve | Vesotsky | 2018 | Community | |
| Lorraine | Wagner | 2005 | ||
| Jerry | Weiss | 2007 | ||
| Tarez | Williams | 2022 | Alumni Association | |
| Sandy | Wizov | Alumni Association | ||
| Eva | Wolf | 1996 | Alumni Association | |
| Charles | Woods | 2000 | Educator | |
| William | Yeats | 1999 | Educator | |
| John | Zerillo | 2009 | Community | |
SPHS Award of Excellence Recipients